AI-generated summary, not yet reviewed by Better Utah staff. Please consult the bill text.

The Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission, the independent panel that reviews Utah judges' performance and provides voters with retention-election ratings, would see its governing law reorganized and updated under this bill. The measure spells out clearer rules for commission meetings and votes, including requirements that votes on whether a judge meets performance standards happen in open, public sessions while individual commissioners' votes remain confidential, and it guarantees a judge the right to appear and speak before the commission if the judge fails to pass certification standards. It also overhauls the judicial performance survey used to gather feedback on judges — expanding who can be surveyed to include, where practical, individuals who appeared in court as a party (not just attorneys, jurors, and court staff) — and restructures the survey questions into new categories covering a judge's legal competence, impartiality, communication skills, temperament, and administrative effectiveness. Finally, the bill directs the commission to study by October 2026 whether a judge's rate of being overturned on appeal should factor into performance evaluations, with a report due to the Legislature's Judiciary Interim Committee by November 2026.