Bill SponsorRep. Matt MacPhersonRepublican
This resolution formally censures Seventh District Court Judge Don M. Torgerson for comments he made during a May 2025 sentencing hearing for a defendant convicted of felony child sexual exploitation, including saying "I've seen worse" after reviewing evidence of child sexual abuse and citing the defendant's "privilege" as a mitigating factor. The House states that these remarks minimized the severity of child rape and violated judicial conduct rules requiring judges to maintain public confidence in the courts and avoid the appearance of bias. The resolution also expresses disappointment with a Utah State Courts statement that the House says inaccurately described the prosecutor's position at the hearing, and directs that copies be sent to Judge Torgerson, the Judicial Conduct Commission, and the Judicial Council. A censure carries no direct legal penalty but places the House's formal condemnation on the record and before the bodies that oversee judicial conduct in Utah.
AI-generated summary, not yet reviewed by Better Utah staff.
AI summaries can make mistakes and leave things out. The bill text is the official version.
This resolution admonishes and censures Judge Don M. Torgerson.
This resolution:
Introduction, completed
Mar 2
House Rules, completed
Mar 2
House committee, completed
House 3rd reading, completed
Mar 3 · 67 to 3 (see the votes)
Introduction, completed
Mar 2
House Rules, completed
Mar 2
House committee, completed
House 3rd reading, completed
Mar 3 · 67 to 3 (see the votes)
Introduction, completed
Mar 2
House Rules, completed
Mar 2
House committee, completed
House 3rd reading, completed
Mar 3 · 67 to 3 (see the votes)
Introduction, completed
Mar 2
House Rules, completed
Mar 2
House committee, completed
House 3rd reading, completed
Mar 3 · 67 to 3 (see the votes)
This resolution formally censures Seventh District Court Judge Don M. Torgerson for comments he made during a May 2025 sentencing hearing for a defendant convicted of felony child sexual exploitation, including saying "I've seen worse" after reviewing evidence of child sexual abuse and citing the defendant's "privilege" as a mitigating factor. The House states that these remarks minimized the severity of child rape and violated judicial conduct rules requiring judges to maintain public confidence in the courts and avoid the appearance of bias. The resolution also expresses disappointment with a Utah State Courts statement that the House says inaccurately described the prosecutor's position at the hearing, and directs that copies be sent to Judge Torgerson, the Judicial Conduct Commission, and the Judicial Council. A censure carries no direct legal penalty but places the House's formal condemnation on the record and before the bodies that oversee judicial conduct in Utah.
AI-generated summary, not yet reviewed by Better Utah staff.
AI summaries can make mistakes and leave things out. The bill text is the official version.
This resolution admonishes and censures Judge Don M. Torgerson.
This resolution:
Loading the versions…
Motion: Favorable recommendation
PASSEDYes 8 · No 0
PASSEDYes 67 · No 3 · Absent 5