Bill SponsorRep. Walt BrooksRepublican
This proposed amendment to the Utah Constitution would give the Legislature power to trigger a special "retention election" — an early up-or-down public vote — on a judge the Legislature determines is unfit, incompetent, persistently slow in deciding cases, or has acted improperly, created an appearance of impropriety, or violated their oath of office. Currently, judges face routine retention elections on a fixed schedule (every 10 years for Supreme Court justices, every 6 years for other judges), but this amendment would let the Legislature initiate an out-of-cycle vote instead, even if the same conduct could also lead to impeachment or judicial discipline proceedings. The Legislature would write the detailed rules in statute for how this special election process works and how to resolve conflicts if multiple removal processes happen at once, and a judge subject to a special election would still face regular retention elections on schedule, except that if both fall in the same year, the special election could substitute for the regular one. Utah voters would first decide whether to add this process to the state constitution, and if approved, it would take effect January 1, 2027.
AI-generated summary, not yet reviewed by Better Utah staff.
AI summaries can make mistakes and leave things out. The bill text is the official version.
Better Utah opposes HJR 13 because it would give the Legislature a new tool to pressure judges and make retention elections more political. The amendment would let lawmakers send any judge to a special election, asking voters whether the judge should stay, whenever they decide the judge is unfit, slow to rule, or has acted in a way that seems improper. Those standards are broad enough to be used against judges over unpopular rulings, and the amendment would let the Legislature skip existing checks like impeachment, which requires a two-thirds Senate vote, and review by the Judicial Conduct Commission. Because the Legislature would also write the rules for how and when these elections happen, the change would shift power away from an independent court system that Utahns rely on for fair decisions.
Better Utah Institute · updated Feb 28
This joint resolution of the Utah Legislature proposes to amend the Utah Constitution to modify provisions related to retention of judges.
This resolution:
Introduction, completed
Jan 20
House Rules, stopped here when the session ended
Session ended
House committee, not yet
House 3rd reading, not yet
Senate Rules, not yet
Senate committee, not yet
Senate 2nd reading, not yet
Senate 3rd reading, not yet
Introduction, completed
Jan 20
House Rules, stopped here when the session ended
Session ended
House committee, not yet
House 3rd reading, not yet
Senate Rules, not yet
Senate committee, not yet
Senate 2nd reading, not yet
Senate 3rd reading, not yet
Introduction, completed
Jan 20
House Rules, stopped here when the session ended
Session ended
House committee, not yet
House 3rd reading, not yet
Senate Rules, not yet
Senate committee, not yet
Senate 2nd reading, not yet
Senate 3rd reading, not yet
Introduction, completed
Jan 20
House Rules, stopped here when the session ended
Session ended
House committee, not yet
House 3rd reading, not yet
Senate Rules, not yet
Senate committee, not yet
Senate 2nd reading, not yet
Senate 3rd reading, not yet
This proposed amendment to the Utah Constitution would give the Legislature power to trigger a special "retention election" — an early up-or-down public vote — on a judge the Legislature determines is unfit, incompetent, persistently slow in deciding cases, or has acted improperly, created an appearance of impropriety, or violated their oath of office. Currently, judges face routine retention elections on a fixed schedule (every 10 years for Supreme Court justices, every 6 years for other judges), but this amendment would let the Legislature initiate an out-of-cycle vote instead, even if the same conduct could also lead to impeachment or judicial discipline proceedings. The Legislature would write the detailed rules in statute for how this special election process works and how to resolve conflicts if multiple removal processes happen at once, and a judge subject to a special election would still face regular retention elections on schedule, except that if both fall in the same year, the special election could substitute for the regular one. Utah voters would first decide whether to add this process to the state constitution, and if approved, it would take effect January 1, 2027.
AI-generated summary, not yet reviewed by Better Utah staff.
AI summaries can make mistakes and leave things out. The bill text is the official version.
Better Utah opposes HJR 13 because it would give the Legislature a new tool to pressure judges and make retention elections more political. The amendment would let lawmakers send any judge to a special election, asking voters whether the judge should stay, whenever they decide the judge is unfit, slow to rule, or has acted in a way that seems improper. Those standards are broad enough to be used against judges over unpopular rulings, and the amendment would let the Legislature skip existing checks like impeachment, which requires a two-thirds Senate vote, and review by the Judicial Conduct Commission. Because the Legislature would also write the rules for how and when these elections happen, the change would shift power away from an independent court system that Utahns rely on for fair decisions.
This joint resolution of the Utah Legislature proposes to amend the Utah Constitution to modify provisions related to retention of judges.
This resolution:
Loading the versions…