Bill SponsorRep. Jason B. KyleRepublican
This proposed constitutional amendment would change how Utah fills judicial vacancies, and voters would have the final say on it in the next general election. Under current law, the Governor must select a judge from a list of at least three candidates certified by a Judicial Nominating Commission, must act within 30 days, and if the Governor misses that deadline, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court makes the appointment instead. This resolution would remove all three of those requirements: the Governor could still ask a commission for a list of candidates but would not be bound by it, could appoint any constitutionally qualified person, would face no deadline to act, and the Chief Justice would no longer have any backup authority to fill the seat. The Senate would still need to approve any judicial appointment by majority vote within 60 days, but the independent commission's role would shift from a required screening step to an optional one the Governor could bypass entirely.
AI-generated summary, not yet reviewed by Better Utah staff.
AI summaries can make mistakes and leave things out. The bill text is the official version.
HJR005 would ask voters to change how Utah picks its judges, and Better Utah opposes it. Right now, the governor must choose a new judge from at least three candidates screened by an independent nominating commission, but this amendment would make that list optional and let the governor appoint anyone who meets the basic requirements. It would also remove the 30-day deadline to fill an open seat and the chief justice's power to step in, so a seat could stay empty with no time limit. The Senate would still have to approve each choice, but we believe losing independent screening would give the governor more control over the courts and weaken their role as a check on the other branches.
Better Utah Institute · updated Feb 28
This joint resolution of the Utah Legislature proposes to amend the Utah Constitution to modify the judicial nominating process.
This resolution:
Introduction, completed
Jan 20
House Rules, stopped here when the session ended
Session ended
House committee, not yet
House 3rd reading, not yet
Senate Rules, not yet
Senate committee, not yet
Senate 2nd reading, not yet
Senate 3rd reading, not yet
Introduction, completed
Jan 20
House Rules, stopped here when the session ended
Session ended
House committee, not yet
House 3rd reading, not yet
Senate Rules, not yet
Senate committee, not yet
Senate 2nd reading, not yet
Senate 3rd reading, not yet
Introduction, completed
Jan 20
House Rules, stopped here when the session ended
Session ended
House committee, not yet
House 3rd reading, not yet
Senate Rules, not yet
Senate committee, not yet
Senate 2nd reading, not yet
Senate 3rd reading, not yet
Introduction, completed
Jan 20
House Rules, stopped here when the session ended
Session ended
House committee, not yet
House 3rd reading, not yet
Senate Rules, not yet
Senate committee, not yet
Senate 2nd reading, not yet
Senate 3rd reading, not yet
This proposed constitutional amendment would change how Utah fills judicial vacancies, and voters would have the final say on it in the next general election. Under current law, the Governor must select a judge from a list of at least three candidates certified by a Judicial Nominating Commission, must act within 30 days, and if the Governor misses that deadline, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court makes the appointment instead. This resolution would remove all three of those requirements: the Governor could still ask a commission for a list of candidates but would not be bound by it, could appoint any constitutionally qualified person, would face no deadline to act, and the Chief Justice would no longer have any backup authority to fill the seat. The Senate would still need to approve any judicial appointment by majority vote within 60 days, but the independent commission's role would shift from a required screening step to an optional one the Governor could bypass entirely.
AI-generated summary, not yet reviewed by Better Utah staff.
AI summaries can make mistakes and leave things out. The bill text is the official version.
HJR005 would ask voters to change how Utah picks its judges, and Better Utah opposes it. Right now, the governor must choose a new judge from at least three candidates screened by an independent nominating commission, but this amendment would make that list optional and let the governor appoint anyone who meets the basic requirements. It would also remove the 30-day deadline to fill an open seat and the chief justice's power to step in, so a seat could stay empty with no time limit. The Senate would still have to approve each choice, but we believe losing independent screening would give the governor more control over the courts and weaken their role as a check on the other branches.
This joint resolution of the Utah Legislature proposes to amend the Utah Constitution to modify the judicial nominating process.
This resolution:
Loading the versions…