Bill SponsorRep. Carol S. MossDemocratFloor SponsorSen. Todd WeilerRepublican
Utah's process for the insanity defense in criminal cases would be substantially revised under this bill. For first-degree or capital felony charges, a defendant claiming not guilty by reason of insanity would have to prove, with "clear and convincing evidence," that a mental condition left them unable to understand the nature of their actions or unable to recognize that those actions were wrong—shifting this burden from the prosecution to the defense. The bill narrows what counts as a qualifying "mental condition," expressly excluding personality disorders, psychopathy, sociopathy, paraphilic disorders such as pedophilia, and issues stemming solely from voluntary intoxication or substance use, while covering conditions like schizophrenia, bipolar I disorder, PTSD, and other serious psychotic disorders; it also gives judges discretion, rather than a mandatory duty, to order a state mental health examination when this defense is raised, and requires at least two examinations by a forensic psychiatrist or psychologist after the defendant is first screened for competency to stand trial. For people already committed to state custody after being found not guilty by reason of insanity, the bill would extend mental health status reviews from every six to every twelve months, require review teams to include forensic specialists who weigh violence-risk factors, add victim notification when a defendant becomes eligible for discharge, and create a new process letting the state temporarily revoke and detain a conditionally released defendant who violates their release plan, followed by court hearings to decide whether the person should be redetained, kept on conditional release, or discharged.
AI-generated summary, not yet reviewed by Better Utah staff.
AI summaries can make mistakes and leave things out. The bill text is the official version.
This bill modifies provisions relating to the criminal defense of not guilty by reason of insanity.
This bill:
Introduction, completed
Feb 4
House Rules, stopped here when the session ended
Session ended
House committee, not yet
House 3rd reading, not yet
Senate Rules, not yet
Senate committee, not yet
Senate 2nd reading, not yet
Senate 3rd reading, not yet
Governor, not yet
Introduction, completed
Feb 4
House Rules, stopped here when the session ended
Session ended
House committee, not yet
House 3rd reading, not yet
Senate Rules, not yet
Senate committee, not yet
Senate 2nd reading, not yet
Senate 3rd reading, not yet
Governor, not yet
Introduction, completed
Feb 4
House Rules, stopped here when the session ended
Session ended
House committee, not yet
House 3rd reading, not yet
Senate Rules, not yet
Senate committee, not yet
Senate 2nd reading, not yet
Senate 3rd reading, not yet
Governor, not yet
Introduction, completed
Feb 4
House Rules, stopped here when the session ended
Session ended
House committee, not yet
House 3rd reading, not yet
Senate Rules, not yet
Senate committee, not yet
Senate 2nd reading, not yet
Senate 3rd reading, not yet
Governor, not yet
Utah's process for the insanity defense in criminal cases would be substantially revised under this bill. For first-degree or capital felony charges, a defendant claiming not guilty by reason of insanity would have to prove, with "clear and convincing evidence," that a mental condition left them unable to understand the nature of their actions or unable to recognize that those actions were wrong—shifting this burden from the prosecution to the defense. The bill narrows what counts as a qualifying "mental condition," expressly excluding personality disorders, psychopathy, sociopathy, paraphilic disorders such as pedophilia, and issues stemming solely from voluntary intoxication or substance use, while covering conditions like schizophrenia, bipolar I disorder, PTSD, and other serious psychotic disorders; it also gives judges discretion, rather than a mandatory duty, to order a state mental health examination when this defense is raised, and requires at least two examinations by a forensic psychiatrist or psychologist after the defendant is first screened for competency to stand trial. For people already committed to state custody after being found not guilty by reason of insanity, the bill would extend mental health status reviews from every six to every twelve months, require review teams to include forensic specialists who weigh violence-risk factors, add victim notification when a defendant becomes eligible for discharge, and create a new process letting the state temporarily revoke and detain a conditionally released defendant who violates their release plan, followed by court hearings to decide whether the person should be redetained, kept on conditional release, or discharged.
AI-generated summary, not yet reviewed by Better Utah staff.
AI summaries can make mistakes and leave things out. The bill text is the official version.
This bill modifies provisions relating to the criminal defense of not guilty by reason of insanity.
This bill:
Loading the versions…
Motion: Held in committee
FAILEDYes 9 · No 0 · Absent 2
Motion: Held in committee
FAILEDYes 7 · No 2 · Absent 2