This bill originally made the judicial nominating commission's screening process mandatory but gave the governor discretion to appoint someone other than the commission's top candidates. The substitute goes further: it makes the entire nominating commission process optional, so the governor could choose to request a list of nominees from a commission when filling a judicial vacancy, or could skip that step altogether. Both versions are contingent on Utah voters approving a related constitutional amendment. If enacted, this measure would eliminate the current requirement that the governor fill a vacancy within 30 days after receiving a commission's list, remove the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court's authority to step in and make the appointment if the governor misses that deadline, and allow the governor to appoint any qualified individual to a judgeship regardless of whether that person applied through, or was recommended by, a nominating commission.
AI-generated summary, not yet reviewed by Better Utah staff.
AI summaries can make mistakes and leave things out. The bill text is the official version.
Better Utah opposes HB 424 because it would weaken the merit-based process Utah uses to choose judges and give one office much more control over the courts. Right now, the governor must pick judges from a short list of top candidates chosen by a nominating commission. This bill would make that list advisory only, and asking for one at all would become optional. It would also remove the 30-day deadline for filling a judge's seat and the chief justice's backup power to fill it, so seats could stay empty with no time limit, and only Senate approval would remain as a check if voters approve a related change to the state constitution.
Better Utah Institute · updated Feb 28
This bill addresses judicial selection.
This bill:
Introduction, completed
Jan 29
House Rules, stopped here when the session ended
Session ended
House committee, not yet
House 3rd reading, not yet
Senate Rules, not yet
Senate committee, not yet
Senate 2nd reading, not yet
Senate 3rd reading, not yet
Governor, not yet
Introduction, completed
Jan 29
House Rules, stopped here when the session ended
Session ended
House committee, not yet
House 3rd reading, not yet
Senate Rules, not yet
Senate committee, not yet
Senate 2nd reading, not yet
Senate 3rd reading, not yet
Governor, not yet
Assigned by Better Utah.
Introduction, completed
Jan 29
House Rules, stopped here when the session ended
Session ended
House committee, not yet
House 3rd reading, not yet
Senate Rules, not yet
Senate committee, not yet
Senate 2nd reading, not yet
Senate 3rd reading, not yet
Governor, not yet
Introduction, completed
Jan 29
House Rules, stopped here when the session ended
Session ended
House committee, not yet
House 3rd reading, not yet
Senate Rules, not yet
Senate committee, not yet
Senate 2nd reading, not yet
Senate 3rd reading, not yet
Governor, not yet
This bill originally made the judicial nominating commission's screening process mandatory but gave the governor discretion to appoint someone other than the commission's top candidates. The substitute goes further: it makes the entire nominating commission process optional, so the governor could choose to request a list of nominees from a commission when filling a judicial vacancy, or could skip that step altogether. Both versions are contingent on Utah voters approving a related constitutional amendment. If enacted, this measure would eliminate the current requirement that the governor fill a vacancy within 30 days after receiving a commission's list, remove the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court's authority to step in and make the appointment if the governor misses that deadline, and allow the governor to appoint any qualified individual to a judgeship regardless of whether that person applied through, or was recommended by, a nominating commission.
AI-generated summary, not yet reviewed by Better Utah staff.
AI summaries can make mistakes and leave things out. The bill text is the official version.
Better Utah opposes HB 424 because it would weaken the merit-based process Utah uses to choose judges and give one office much more control over the courts. Right now, the governor must pick judges from a short list of top candidates chosen by a nominating commission. This bill would make that list advisory only, and asking for one at all would become optional. It would also remove the 30-day deadline for filling a judge's seat and the chief justice's backup power to fill it, so seats could stay empty with no time limit, and only Senate approval would remain as a check if voters approve a related change to the state constitution.
This bill addresses judicial selection.
This bill:
Loading the versions…