Bill SponsorRep. Matt MacPhersonRepublicanFloor SponsorSen. Michael K. McKellRepublican
Current version: HB0392S03 (substitute)
Utah's courts would change how civil lawsuits involving state law and state government are handled. The attorney general would have an unconditional right to join any district court civil case once notified that a party is challenging a state law as unconstitutional, in addition to the Legislature's existing right to intervene. When a state agency or state official is a party to a district court civil case, the attorney general, governor, or Legislature could file a notice, which no party could challenge and no court could review, requiring the case to be heard by three randomly selected district judges from different judicial districts. The panel would decide by majority vote, its rulings would be appealed directly to the Utah Supreme Court, and normal rules on where a case must be filed would not apply. The Judicial Council would have to set up the random selection process, keep a list of eligible judges, and hire staff to support the panels.
AI-generated summary, reviewed by Better Utah staff.
AI summaries can make mistakes and leave things out. The bill text is the official version.
When the state or a state official is sued in a civil case, HB 392 would let the attorney general, the governor, or the Legislature move the case from one judge to a panel of three district judges, and no party could challenge that choice or ask a court to review it. Better Utah opposes the bill because it gives only the government's side of a lawsuit the power to change how the case is heard and blocks the courts from checking that decision. The bill would also set aside the usual rules about where a case is heard, give the attorney general an automatic right to join any district court case challenging whether a state law is constitutional, and require courts to hire new staff without providing any money. Courts can only serve as a fair check on the other branches when both sides play by the same rules, and this bill tilts those rules toward the state.
Better Utah Institute · updated Feb 28
This bill addresses civil actions in the district court.
This bill:
Introduction, completed
Jan 27
House Rules, completed
Jan 27
House committee, completed
Jan 28 · Recommended, 7 to 2 (see the votes)
House 3rd reading, completed
Feb 4 · 56 to 15 (see the votes)
Senate Rules, completed
Feb 5
Senate committee, completed
Senate 2nd reading, completed
Feb 11 · 21 to 7 (see the votes)
Senate 3rd reading, completed
Feb 12 · 22 to 7 (see the votes)
House concurrence, completed
Feb 13 · 55 to 16 (see the votes)
Governor signed, completed
Feb 13
Introduction, completed
Jan 27
House Rules, completed
Jan 27
House committee, completed
Jan 28 · Recommended, 7 to 2 (see the votes)
House 3rd reading, completed
Feb 4 · 56 to 15 (see the votes)
Senate Rules, completed
Feb 5
Senate committee, completed
Senate 2nd reading, completed
Feb 11 · 21 to 7 (see the votes)
Senate 3rd reading, completed
Feb 12 · 22 to 7 (see the votes)
House concurrence, completed
Feb 13 · 55 to 16 (see the votes)
Governor signed, completed
Feb 13
Assigned by Better Utah.
Current version: HB0392S03 (substitute)
Introduction, completed
Jan 27
House Rules, completed
Jan 27
House committee, completed
Jan 28 · Recommended, 7 to 2 (see the votes)
House 3rd reading, completed
Feb 4 · 56 to 15 (see the votes)
Senate Rules, completed
Feb 5
Senate committee, completed
Senate 2nd reading, completed
Feb 11 · 21 to 7 (see the votes)
Senate 3rd reading, completed
Feb 12 · 22 to 7 (see the votes)
House concurrence, completed
Feb 13 · 55 to 16 (see the votes)
Governor signed, completed
Feb 13
Introduction, completed
Jan 27
House Rules, completed
Jan 27
House committee, completed
Jan 28 · Recommended, 7 to 2 (see the votes)
House 3rd reading, completed
Feb 4 · 56 to 15 (see the votes)
Senate Rules, completed
Feb 5
Senate committee, completed
Senate 2nd reading, completed
Feb 11 · 21 to 7 (see the votes)
Senate 3rd reading, completed
Feb 12 · 22 to 7 (see the votes)
House concurrence, completed
Feb 13 · 55 to 16 (see the votes)
Governor signed, completed
Feb 13
Utah's courts would change how civil lawsuits involving state law and state government are handled. The attorney general would have an unconditional right to join any district court civil case once notified that a party is challenging a state law as unconstitutional, in addition to the Legislature's existing right to intervene. When a state agency or state official is a party to a district court civil case, the attorney general, governor, or Legislature could file a notice, which no party could challenge and no court could review, requiring the case to be heard by three randomly selected district judges from different judicial districts. The panel would decide by majority vote, its rulings would be appealed directly to the Utah Supreme Court, and normal rules on where a case must be filed would not apply. The Judicial Council would have to set up the random selection process, keep a list of eligible judges, and hire staff to support the panels.
AI-generated summary, reviewed by Better Utah staff.
AI summaries can make mistakes and leave things out. The bill text is the official version.
When the state or a state official is sued in a civil case, HB 392 would let the attorney general, the governor, or the Legislature move the case from one judge to a panel of three district judges, and no party could challenge that choice or ask a court to review it. Better Utah opposes the bill because it gives only the government's side of a lawsuit the power to change how the case is heard and blocks the courts from checking that decision. The bill would also set aside the usual rules about where a case is heard, give the attorney general an automatic right to join any district court case challenging whether a state law is constitutional, and require courts to hire new staff without providing any money. Courts can only serve as a fair check on the other branches when both sides play by the same rules, and this bill tilts those rules toward the state.
This bill addresses civil actions in the district court.
This bill:
Loading the versions…
Motion: Favorable recommendation
PASSEDYes 7 · No 2 · Absent 2
PASSEDYes 56 · No 15 · Absent 4
Motion: Favorable recommendation
PASSEDYes 4 · No 1 · Absent 2
PASSEDYes 21 · No 7 · Absent 1
PASSEDYes 22 · No 7
PASSEDYes 55 · No 16 · Absent 4