Bill SponsorRep. Jordan D. TeuscherRepublicanFloor SponsorSen. Brady BrammerRepublican
Current version: HB0366S03 (substitute)
Utah's court system would see several changes to how cases are handled and how the courts operate. The bill updates the ballot language voters see when deciding whether to retain a judge in office, changes how and when the Business and Chancery Court publishes its decisions and issues tentative rulings, requires district courts to transfer certain cases to the Business and Chancery Court when appropriate, and sets rules for assigning district court judges to handle criminal cases that municipalities file or appeal. It also clarifies that an appeal challenging a court's injunction against a state law goes directly to the Supreme Court rather than the Court of Appeals. Separately, and only if a court strikes down or blocks the state's current three-judge panel process for constitutional challenges, the bill would create a new "Constitutional Court" — a three-judge, statewide trial court dedicated to hearing civil constitutional challenges against the state — complete with its own nominating commission for selecting judges, salary structure, retention election rules, staff, and administrative framework within the broader court system.
AI-generated summary, not yet reviewed by Better Utah staff.
AI summaries can make mistakes and leave things out. The bill text is the official version.
Because Utah's courts should stay an independent check on the other branches of government, Better Utah Institute opposes HB 366. The bill sets up a backup three-judge Constitutional Court, with its own nominating commission, that would start only if courts strike down or block certain other new rules for how some cases are heard. Creating a new court that switches on when the current approach is blocked risks reshaping the courts to steer legal challenges rather than to serve Utahns. The bill also adds a $1,500 fee to request a three-judge panel in these cases, a new cost that could make it harder for Utahns to ask the courts to review state laws.
Better Utah Institute · updated Oct 15
This bill addresses issues related to the judiciary.
This bill:
Introduction, completed
Jan 26
House Rules, completed
Feb 4
House committee, completed
Feb 11 · Recommended, 8 to 1 (see the votes)
House 3rd reading, completed
Feb 19 · 66 to 2 (see the votes)
Senate Rules, completed
Feb 23
Senate committee, completed
Feb 25 · Recommended, 5 to 0 (see the votes)
Senate 2nd reading, completed
Mar 5
Senate 3rd reading, completed
Mar 5 · 23 to 6 (see the votes)
House concurrence, completed
Mar 5 · 55 to 18 (see the votes)
Governor signed, completed
Mar 13
Introduction, completed
Jan 26
House Rules, completed
Feb 4
House committee, completed
Feb 11 · Recommended, 8 to 1 (see the votes)
House 3rd reading, completed
Feb 19 · 66 to 2 (see the votes)
Senate Rules, completed
Feb 23
Senate committee, completed
Feb 25 · Recommended, 5 to 0 (see the votes)
Senate 2nd reading, completed
Mar 5
Senate 3rd reading, completed
Mar 5 · 23 to 6 (see the votes)
House concurrence, completed
Mar 5 · 55 to 18 (see the votes)
Governor signed, completed
Mar 13
Assigned by Better Utah.
Current version: HB0366S03 (substitute)
Introduction, completed
Jan 26
House Rules, completed
Feb 4
House committee, completed
Feb 11 · Recommended, 8 to 1 (see the votes)
House 3rd reading, completed
Feb 19 · 66 to 2 (see the votes)
Senate Rules, completed
Feb 23
Senate committee, completed
Feb 25 · Recommended, 5 to 0 (see the votes)
Senate 2nd reading, completed
Mar 5
Senate 3rd reading, completed
Mar 5 · 23 to 6 (see the votes)
House concurrence, completed
Mar 5 · 55 to 18 (see the votes)
Governor signed, completed
Mar 13
Introduction, completed
Jan 26
House Rules, completed
Feb 4
House committee, completed
Feb 11 · Recommended, 8 to 1 (see the votes)
House 3rd reading, completed
Feb 19 · 66 to 2 (see the votes)
Senate Rules, completed
Feb 23
Senate committee, completed
Feb 25 · Recommended, 5 to 0 (see the votes)
Senate 2nd reading, completed
Mar 5
Senate 3rd reading, completed
Mar 5 · 23 to 6 (see the votes)
House concurrence, completed
Mar 5 · 55 to 18 (see the votes)
Governor signed, completed
Mar 13
Utah's court system would see several changes to how cases are handled and how the courts operate. The bill updates the ballot language voters see when deciding whether to retain a judge in office, changes how and when the Business and Chancery Court publishes its decisions and issues tentative rulings, requires district courts to transfer certain cases to the Business and Chancery Court when appropriate, and sets rules for assigning district court judges to handle criminal cases that municipalities file or appeal. It also clarifies that an appeal challenging a court's injunction against a state law goes directly to the Supreme Court rather than the Court of Appeals. Separately, and only if a court strikes down or blocks the state's current three-judge panel process for constitutional challenges, the bill would create a new "Constitutional Court" — a three-judge, statewide trial court dedicated to hearing civil constitutional challenges against the state — complete with its own nominating commission for selecting judges, salary structure, retention election rules, staff, and administrative framework within the broader court system.
AI-generated summary, not yet reviewed by Better Utah staff.
AI summaries can make mistakes and leave things out. The bill text is the official version.
Because Utah's courts should stay an independent check on the other branches of government, Better Utah Institute opposes HB 366. The bill sets up a backup three-judge Constitutional Court, with its own nominating commission, that would start only if courts strike down or block certain other new rules for how some cases are heard. Creating a new court that switches on when the current approach is blocked risks reshaping the courts to steer legal challenges rather than to serve Utahns. The bill also adds a $1,500 fee to request a three-judge panel in these cases, a new cost that could make it harder for Utahns to ask the courts to review state laws.
This bill addresses issues related to the judiciary.
This bill:
Loading the versions…
Motion: Favorable recommendation
PASSEDYes 8 · No 1 · Absent 2
PASSEDYes 66 · No 2 · Absent 7
Motion: Favorable recommendation
PASSEDYes 5 · No 0 · Absent 2
PASSEDYes 23 · No 6
PASSEDYes 55 · No 18 · Absent 2